Tibet Pointe Circle runs inside the Keene's Pointe gate in Windermere, and in 2026 it had four recorded sales at four very different prices. The first came on March 13, when 9204 Tibet Pointe Circle sold for $2,250,000. The West Orange Times & Observer's weekly sales column listed it at 5,291 square feet and 84 days on market. On June 5, 9121 Tibet Pointe Circle sold for $13,200,000 five days after listing. Thirteen days after that, 9259 Tibet Pointe Circle closed at $6,050,000. That house has 6,257 square feet, direct frontage on Lake Tibet and a 2025 renovation. On August 20, 9222 Tibet Pointe Circle sold for $2,425,000 at 5,323 square feet.
Divide each price by its living area. The two houses near 5,300 square feet sold for about $425 and $456 a square foot. The renovated house on the lake, only about 950 square feet larger, sold for roughly $967 a square foot. All three share a street name, a gate, a golf club and a ZIP code. The difference in price came from what the back of each lot touches.
That pattern holds across the whole community. This piece sorts a year of Keene's Pointe sales, as reported week by week in the Observer from November 2025 through early November 2026, by what each lot backs onto.
Two kinds of lakefront behind one gate
Most buyers learn first that Keene's Pointe sits on the Butler Chain of Lakes. The next thing to learn is that it fronts two kinds of water, and only one of them is the chain.
The Orange County Water Atlas lists the Butler Chain as 13 interconnected lakes with more than 5,000 acres of surface water and 32 navigable canals. Tibet-Butler, at 1,200 acres, is one of the 13, and so is Lake Isleworth at 86 acres. Lake Burden is not on that list. The Water Atlas places it in the wider Windermere Water Navigation Control District, a 27-lake taxing district, but outside the chain itself.
A Keene's Pointe home with water behind it can therefore mean either of two things. Frontage on Tibet-Butler or Isleworth puts the lot on the chain. Frontage on Lake Burden gives water views and lake life on a lake that is not one of the chain's 13. Inside the community, chain frontage is concentrated on Tibet Pointe Circle, Greatwater Drive, Grosvenor Shore Drive and Grosvenor Pointe Circle. The Lake Burden lots are mostly on Vinci Drive and Mattina Court, with a few more on Tibet Butler Drive and Lake Burden Circle. Even on the chain streets, plenty of lots face the street or the course instead of the water. The two mid-$2 million sales on Tibet Pointe Circle show it.
On the chain, the water sets the per-foot price
Sales on the streets that carry chain frontage, or that the Observer described as lakefront, cluster at a price level that only one off-chain sale reached in this window.
On May 11, 6013 Greatwater Drive sold for $6,700,000 after 11 days on market. At 7,607 square feet, that works out to about $881 a square foot. On May 28, 6137 Grosvenor Shore Drive, which the Observer described as sitting on the shores of Lake Tibet, sold for $7,650,000, about $799 a square foot across 9,571 square feet. On June 30, on the same street, 6142 Grosvenor Shore Drive closed at $4,850,000 for 6,950 square feet, close to $698 a square foot. Earlier in the year, 9733 Carillon Park Drive, another chain-frontage street, sold for $5,000,000 on March 12 after five days on market.
The time on market is where chain homes differ most from one another. The Grosvenor Shore sale at $7.65 million took 344 days. The Greatwater sale took 11, and Carillon Park took 5. A lake lot's value is fairly predictable. The asking price a seller attaches to the house on it is less so, and the calendar records the difference. The few buyers shopping at this level move fast on a number they agree with and wait out a number they don't.
The $13.2 million sale at 9121 Tibet Pointe Circle stands apart from this group. The Adams Equities deed-record list ranks it among the highest single-family sales recorded in Orange County since 2000 and lists the parcel at 4.43 acres. The Observer's description of the house focused on its resort-style pool, with a slide, a waterfall, a diving rock and swim-up seating. The 4.43 acres, the house and its finishes carried that price, so it says little about what a typical chain lot is worth.
Lake Burden prices like a large fairway home
Sales on the Lake Burden streets landed much closer to the golf-course homes than to the chain. On June 24, 8340 Lake Burden Circle sold for $3,250,000 for 6,848 square feet, about $475 a square foot, after seven days on market. On May 5, 8402 Lake Burden Circle closed at $2,400,000 for 6,248 square feet, roughly $384 a square foot, after 155 days. On Vinci Drive, 11753 Vinci Drive sold for $1,980,000 on August 7 after 19 days on market.
The exception shows the condition that moves a Lake Burden price. A newly built home on Boyla Court with Lake Burden frontage closed at $6.7 million on November 13. On Burden, the new house took that sale into the chain's price range. On Tibet Pointe Circle, an older house with chain frontage, renovated in 2025, reached $967 a square foot.
A buyer weighing a Lake Burden home against a chain home is therefore pricing two different things. One is a large house on a lake outside the chain's 13. The other is a lot on the chain itself, a boating system that covers more than 5,000 acres.
The fairway sits at the middle of the market
The Golden Bear Club's course runs through most of Keene's Pointe. It is a private Jack Nicklaus Signature 18-hole course, and the club sets its own golf and social memberships. Whitford Court, South Hampshire Court and Valhalla Way are almost entirely golf lots, while streets such as Claymont Circle and Bowden Way have none.
Golf-lot sales formed the steadiest group in the year. On November 12, 2025, 6030 Greatwater Drive sold for $3,178,500 after four days on market. The Observer noted the fairway view from its primary suite. At 6,489 square feet, that is about $490 a square foot. On May 8, 6133 S. Hampshire Court sold for $3,000,000 after two days on market, about $474 a square foot. On August 31, 6857 Valhalla Way sold for $3,300,000, about $461 a square foot across 7,153 square feet.
Those three sales land within about $30 a square foot of each other, all near $460 to $490. Greatwater Drive also shows how far apart two lots on one street can price. In the same twelve months that 6013 Greatwater sold for $6.7 million on the water, 6036 Greatwater sold on July 24 for $1,875,000 at 4,013 square feet. That is a 3.5x spread in price on one street, set by what each lot backs onto.
The interior streets carry the entry price, and pricing carries the clock
The lots that touch neither water nor course set the community's entry price. These are the streets where the Keene's Pointe gate and club setting cost the least.
On Camden Park Drive, sales ran from $945,000 for 11866 Camden Park Drive on June 30 to $1,550,000 for 11952 Camden Park Drive on May 20. Bowden Way had three sales. 8350 Bowden Way sold for $1,115,000 on May 11 after five days. Across the street, 8351 Bowden Way sold for $960,000 on August 21 after 130 days. The most recent sale in the Observer's log is 8525 Bowden Way, which closed at $900,000 on November 6 after 168 days on market.
Days on market among these homes vary as much as on the chain, and they show how a list price meets the market. Interior homes that sat past 120 days include 6161 Blakeford Drive at 190 days and $1,600,000 in January, and 6110 Keene's Pointe Drive at 126 days and $1,650,000 in August. In Stellar MLS closed-sale records for the twelve months through early November 2026, Keene's Pointe homes that never cut their price went under contract in a median of about four weeks and closed near 95 percent of asking. Homes that needed a reduction took a median of roughly five months and still closed below their reduced number. For a seller, the community median matters less than whether the first list price matches what the lot behind the house is worth.
What is asking now
As this post publishes, one chain listing asks far more than anything that closed this year. 6119 Grosvenor Shore Drive, a 14,068-square-foot Lake Tibet estate that the Orlando Business Journal covered when it was listed in July, is asking $15.9 million. As of mid-November it had been on the market for about four months. On Tibet Pointe Circle, 9343 is asking $7.45 million with a private dock and boat lift on Lake Tibet, and 9349 is asking $6.995 million with Tibet-Butler frontage.
Measured against the year's closed sales, the two Tibet Pointe asks sit within the $6 million to $7.65 million range that renovated and larger chain homes reached in 2026. The Grosvenor Shore ask is about double that range. For a buyer, each of these listings raises a separate question. On a chain lot, ask how the house compares to the 2026 chain sales. On a fairway lot, ask whether the price fits the narrow $460 to $490 per-foot band. On an interior lot, ask whether the list price looks like a five-day sale or a five-month one.
A few questions buyers ask about Keene's Pointe
Is every Lake Burden home on the Butler Chain? No. The Orange County Water Atlas lists Lake Burden in the Windermere Water Navigation Control District but not among the chain's 13 interconnected lakes. Tibet-Butler and Isleworth are the chain lakes that Keene's Pointe lots touch.
Does a street name tell me whether a home is on the water? Not reliably. Tibet Pointe Circle had 2026 sales at $2.25 million and $2.425 million alongside a $6.05 million sale with direct Lake Tibet frontage. Greatwater Drive ranged from $1.875 million to $6.7 million.
Where do sales sit in the middle of the market? Golf-course homes. The Greatwater, South Hampshire and Valhalla sales from November 2025 through August 2026 each closed at about $460 to $490 a square foot.
The Windermere advisors at Elite Sport Network can set any Keene's Pointe address against the chain, Lake Burden and fairway sales of the past year before you tour, and can schedule showings privately for clients whose calendars leave little room for open houses. Book a private consultation and bring the addresses you are weighing on Tibet Pointe Circle, Greatwater Drive or Vinci Drive.