A modern home's bronze-framed glass corner beneath a low roof, with limestone paving and a specimen lady palm after rain.

Casa Feliz Turns 25 This Sunday. The Next Gamble Rogers House Waits on November 11.

The bell tower at 656 N. Park Ave. will ring on Sunday for a house that has stood on its current lot for a quarter-century. Rogers designed Casa Feliz in 1932, and it was completed in 1933 about 300 yards away, across Interlachen Avenue. It got to the edge of the Winter Park Golf Course on hydraulic dollies in September 2001. The house sits there because a group of neighbors, a pair of bald eagles and a city willing to take it on all got involved before a demolition crew finished the job.

Three days before the 25th Anniversary Community Day, Winter Park is again deciding how much of a James Gamble Rogers II house survives on a lakefront lot. This time the house is Merrywood, Rogers' largest, at 1020 Palmer Ave. Moving it is not on the table. The City Commission picks the question back up on November 11.

Sunday on North Park Avenue

The Friends of Casa Feliz are hosting a free, family-friendly celebration on Sunday, October 25, from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. No RSVP is needed. The program on the official anniversary page includes:

  • Live music from Rosie O'Grady's Good Time Jazz Quartet, Baila Al Alma Flamenco and Intersectus Jazz Trio.
  • A new poem. Former U.S. Poet Laureate Billy Collins will read "An Interview with Casa Feliz," which he wrote for the occasion.
  • A mayoral proclamation recognizing the community effort that saved the house, followed by a ceremonial bell-ringing.
  • Ice cream. Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream made an anniversary flavor, Casa Feliz Roof Tile Crunch, with free scoops for the first 500 guests.
  • Lunch. Pizza and barbecue will be for sale.
  • A premiere. A new short documentary about the anniversary will play in the Garden Room.

Winter Park Magazine's preview adds storytelling, souvenir crafts and a large-format historical display for children and families.

The film and the display tell the story of how the house got to this lot. That story matters again this fall, because Merrywood's fate turns on the same question.

How a 1932 Farmhouse Ended Up Beside a Golf Course

Rogers designed the Andalusian-style masonry farmhouse for Massachusetts industrialist Robert Bruce Barbour. Winter Park Magazine reports that Barbour told him, "Design it any way you like. If I don't like it, I'll sell it." Barbour liked it. He and his wife, Nettie, hosted dozens of community gatherings in the 5,400-square-foot house.

Year What happened
1932 Rogers designs the house for Robert Bruce Barbour
1933 The house is completed
1941 Barbour dies; Nettie Barbour stays in the house
1951 Nettie Barbour sells; a series of owners follows
September 2000 A new owner begins demolition to build a new house
2000 to 2001 Friends of Casa Feliz forms and raises money for a move
September 2001 The house is rolled across Interlachen Avenue to city land
2001 to 2004 Restoration; the first wedding at the house in fall 2004
March 5, 2005 Official public opening

The magazine's account of the middle decades is blunt. As property values rose, buyers came to see "more value in the dirt beneath them than in the sometimes-quirky old structures that fronted the city's brick-lined streets."

The Trade That Saved It

Casa Feliz was saved because the house and the land were separated.

Winter Park Magazine gives the sequence. A newly formed group, Friends of Casa Feliz, got a reprieve when a protected bald eagle's nest was found on the property, and the demolition permit was temporarily rescinded. In that window, advocates raised more than $1.2 million from 400 individual donors. The owners then gave the house to the city on one condition: it had to leave. Contractors moved the whole building, all of it, to a city lot next to the golf course. Casa Feliz's own timeline puts its weight at 800 tons. Restoration took several more years, helped by a $250,000 grant from the state Division of Historical Resources.

The house left its original lot, and the city got all of it. Every room, the bell tower and the roof tiles that inspired Sunday's ice cream all made the trip. Today the city owns Casa Feliz and the Friends of Casa Feliz run it. The house hosts the Music at the Casa series, the Parlor Series talks and a steady calendar of private events.

"Casa Feliz is only here because a community decided that its architectural history mattered. Twenty-five years later, we want to celebrate not only the saving of the house, but the thousands of people who have passed through its doors and helped give it a vibrant second life."

Betsy Owens, the executive director of the Friends of Casa Feliz and Rogers' granddaughter, said this to Winter Park Magazine ahead of the anniversary.

Merrywood: Same Architect, Different Trade

According to the Friends of Casa Feliz, Merrywood is the Caroline Griggs Plant House on Lake Osceola, designed by Rogers and finished in 1939. At about 7,000 square feet it is the largest house he ever built.

Its legal position is weaker than its reputation. Winter Park Voice reported in March that the previous owners filed a demolition application. Because Merrywood is listed in the Florida Master Site File, that filing set off a 90-day delay. But the house is not on Winter Park's local historic register, and the Voice later reported that the city extended the demolition permit in August.

The property sold this summer. The Voice reported a deed dated August 18, 2026, transferring it to Lake Osceola Holdings LLC for $15 million. The Voice says that is the highest sale price ever recorded in Winter Park. On June 24, before the sale closed, the commission voted 3-2 on a first reading of a comprehensive-plan change that would let qualifying lakefront lots be split. That version did not require historic designation. It capped the two future homes at a combined 30,000 square feet and required one of them to be built in a style close to Rogers'.

So the deal under negotiation is the reverse of 2001. In 2001 the whole house moved off its lot. Merrywood's owner is asking to divide the lot, and the question is how much of the house stays as part of that deal. The Voice notes the property would become even more valuable if it were subdivided so part could be sold separately.

What Happened on October 14

The second reading came before the commission on October 14. Winter Park Voice reported that the meeting ran more than four hours. According to that report, the owner said a close family friend wanted to buy the new lot and build there. He said he planned to build a new house for his family behind Merrywood, with the existing house at least partly demolished and turned into a guest house.

Commissioner Kris Cruzada had voted for the lot split in June without preservation conditions. This time he pushed for a compromise that would keep part of Merrywood in exchange for allowing the split. Commissioners talked about saving only part of the facade, the front wall, and gutting everything behind it. The commission then voted 5-0 to delay a decision. The city's official meeting recap records Ordinance 3368-26, the request from Lake Osceola Holdings LLC, as tabled until November 11, 2026.

The Friends of Casa Feliz, the same group that spent 2001 raising money for a house move, are involved again. The Voice reports that they helped look for buyers who would preserve Merrywood. They also organized an open letter, signed by nearly 300 people, asking the city to make historic designation a condition of the lot split. The group's director urged that at least 80% of the house be kept, including the front elevation.

The Winter Park History Museum has also weighed in. As Winter Park Voice reported in March, its executive director argued that saving tangible historic places matters alongside saving archives.

As of this week, Merrywood is still standing and its future is open. If the lot-split request fails, the demolition permit is still a live option.

Between the Bell and the Vote

Casa Feliz shows what came out of the 2001 trade. You can walk through it on Sunday, and on any ordinary week after that. Here is the calendar for the next few weeks:

  1. Sunday, October 25, 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. The 25th Anniversary Community Day at 656 N. Park Ave. It is free and needs no RSVP.
  2. Every Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. Docent-led tours of Casa Feliz start at 10:15, 11:15, 12:15 and 1:15. The suggested contribution is $5 per adult. Details are on the Casa Feliz tour page.
  3. Wednesday, November 11. The City Commission takes up the second reading of Ordinance 3368-26, the Merrywood lot-split request, which was tabled on October 14.

A weekday tour shows the full house the 2001 deal saved, including the rooms Barbour hosted in, the bell tower and the roofline. Facade retention is the middle ground Merrywood's owner and the commission are now working through. For more of Rogers' work and the city's other historic styles, our guide to Winter Park's historic home styles and our look at architecture and design themes in Winter Park are a good next read. Our Winter Park neighborhood page covers the rest of the city.

Historic houses on Winter Park's lakes come with questions about permits, registers and lot lines, and those questions often matter long before closing. The advisors at Elite Sport Network work with these architecturally significant properties discreetly and with care for what the house means to the street. If you own one or are thinking about it, book a private consultation.

Work With Us

Focus on your career, we’ll focus on finding you a home.

Follow Me On Instagram